No big surprise last night on Idol when Naima and Thia got voted off the show. But what about Paul?Eventually, all but one has to go and of course that "one" should be Pia. So, did America get it right last night? In my opinion, we did not! If you base it solely on the performances from Wednesday night, it should have been Naima and Paul to leave the show. Naima's Elton John reggae rendition was an insult to one of the best musical talents of our time and Paul - don't get me started on his performance of "Rocket Man", it certainly was NOT "out of this world".

See Naima's and Paul's performances here.