11 Popular Misconceptions About Amish Life in Michigan

If you've always been curious about what happens down those unpaved, two-track roads that lead to Amish communities in Michigan, you're not alone. World Population Review reports that, as of 2024, the Mitten State is sixth in the country for Amish population, with 20,690 living in Michigan in 52 communities. However, if you've never had the opportunity to explore the Pennsylvania Dutch-speaking lifestyle, you may have one or more misconceptions about their day-to-day lives and religious practices.

RELATED: 11 Rules Amish Women in Michigan Must Obey

Different Sects, Different Practices

TV shows, Hollywood, and misinformed tourists create many Amish myths. For instance, each of Michigan's communities may have different rules. There are various sects, such as the Old Order, New Order, and Swartzentruber, each with its own set of rules.

Who Sets the Rules?

While each has slightly different beliefs and rules, these rules are typically established by the elders in each settlement. Therefore, when traveling between Old Order communities in Michigan, you may find differences in practices.

Get our free mobile app

For instance, you may believe that the Amish are forbidden from interacting with people outside their community. While this might be true for individuals, most enjoy conversing with "The English" and are quite welcoming to outsiders.

If you do want to strike up a conversation, it is considered rude to address Amish women directly, so be sure to approach an elder male to open up a dialogue.

Related: 5 Do’s and 5 Don’ts For Exploring Michigan Amish Country

11 Myths About Amish Life in Michigan: Fact vs. Fiction

Amish culture is more than farming, driving buggies, and using wood stoves. These Michigan communities are evolving and are more complex and practical than many think.