Jiwan James plays center field for the Reading Phillies, and recently made the most amazing catch I have ever seen . . . or did he?

The first 50 times you see this catch you'll wonder how it happened.  How could it so clearly not have landed in his glove, yet he still comes down with the ball?

Not just appearing to make the catch, but coming down with it bare handed at that?

Withleather.com breaks down four possible theories put out there by YouTube commentors.

Watch Jiwan James amazing catch and let us know what you think happened.